There seems to be this trend among non-typset geeks who nevertheless want to sound like a typeset geek to arbitrarily hate on some of the more popularly-hated fonts. With some fonts, where the proper application is reasonably uncommon, this is more or less justifiable. I know that Comic Sans is out of place in almost every context, and I know I received one too many handouts in high school written in it. But there’s one I haven’t quite been able to understand: Papyrus. It is not, taken in isolation, a particularly ugly font. There are, naturally, websites collecting its use, and I can even agree that in a good number of examples they could have found a better font. But I’m really of no mind to start hating the font merely because it captures the mind of unimaginative restaurant owners. (Related: I know a comic that uses Comic Sans in its word bubbles. It works just fine.)
The most interesting part of this, for me, is the reaction when Randall Munroe wrote a comic about it. A number of xkcd fanboys were quick to declare their hatred for the font, as well. They were, that is, until someone pointed out that the movie Serenity uses it in its logo. Turns out, most of them couldn’t even identify the font when used relatively appropriately in a logo. Hmm.
Some of the more design-oriented types who complain about it seem to believe they know exactly what the individual is thinking when they select Papyrus as a font. They seem to believe that there is a conscious design decision here, that non-designers put a great deal of forethought into arbitrary selections of fonts. They assume they must weigh all of the options they have available to them. “What does this font say about me/my store/my event?” the design geeks think they are asking.
Here’s what actually happens. The thought process runs roughly like this: “Oh, I need a font. Let’s see what’s available. Oh, Papyrus sounds interesting. Hey, that doesn’t look bad, let’s go with that.”
I’m fine with disliking fonts. The seething disdain, the disproportionate hatred, however, I’m really not cool with. Do try to keep it in perspective.
5 Responses »